Showing posts with label essay writing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label essay writing. Show all posts

Monday, 26 May 2008

Finishing up


When I finished writing my answers, I'd get a feeling like this picture. Rays of tranquility, the stillness of having finished...aaah it's all over.

The trouble is I got this feeling prematurely: when you finish writing you still have one job to do. Checking it over. If I am honest, not every essay I wrote in exams was read through and checked either because I ran out of time or steam (or had lapsed into a world of romanticised classical imagery.)

This is bad time management and a bad attitude to have. On those essays I did check over I always found a slew of glaring errors. On the ones that didn't get the once over I probably cost myself. I would advise you hold off the feeling of relief at the end of writing for a bit longer and leave yourself a couple of mins at the end of an essay to go back over and brush it up. Silly mistakes upset markers - and grumpy markers get stingy with marks.

The first five mins


Read the questions sloooowwwly

When the exam starts read the questions carefully. Sounds bleedin' obvious, doesn't it? But panic does funny things to us. Time feels like it's slipping away and reading the questions speedily is the outcome of this feeling. Besides, what you nod at here isn't often what you actually do. To make sure I read them properly, I didn't read them 'in my head' but as if I were reading them out loud, just with no volume.

I'd spend 2 minutes reading the questions over and over. Sometimes one will jump out and give you a big wet kiss, other times it will twist in front of your eyes, changing shape every time you look at it.

I like to choose both questions before I start under the belief that somewhere some portion of my brain might be thinking about the other question sub-consciously whilst I answer the other (I have no idea whether this is true, it just seems like it might be from experience).

Put your answer's gist in a nutshell

Before embarking on your answer have a casual sentence or two in your head to sum up what your main argument will be. Some examples:
  • [Human Factors & Error] 'Sure, human error is unavoidable but user-centred design can make systems more tolerant of error'
  • [Neuropsychiatry] 'Yes, psychiatry and neurology should be merged for theoretical reasons (they both deal with breakdowns in the same system)
For people confident with their stuff, I'd advise adding on a modifier to this mental statement. This will refine your argument, show caution (a good thing) and tick the box for critical analysis. Building on the examples I gave you a moment ago:
  • [Human Factors & Error] '...While systems can be polished, we must not forget - and remove all the blame from - humans: as operators, their cognitive systems can be polished too by training';
  • [Neuropsychiatry] '...Whilst Neuropsychiatry is theoretically ideal it may be practically impossible to be sufficiently expert in. Therefore, although the two should be reunited, the sub-disciplines of psychiatry and neurology should exist within the framework of neuropsychiatry';
If you do this, what you have is the last sentence of your introduction and the spine of your essay which you can add the muscle to when you are writing it. It will keep you focused.

If you are write-down-plan sort of person spend the next few mins making that. If you are a do-it-in-your-head-plan type (like me) make sure it's solid and then start writing...

Wednesday, 21 May 2008

How to be the cream

I had this scheduled to post a while back before all the exams kicked off but something went wrong with Blogger for some strange reason. Here it is now though.


A pint of Guinness tonight and a couple of emails from you lot got me thinking about the difference between a 2.1 and the a First. What does it take to be the cream at the top?

Having produced essays that range from shrugging 2.2 all the way up to a party-throwing nineteen, I have had a crack at analysing what I think works.

I know it says a little bit in the handbook about what a makes a First but here's my take on the sine non qua of the undergraduate black belt.

Flawless basics

Getting the basics right might sound obvious and easy but it is often neither. Perfect writing takes skill, which means practice. You might also be thinking that it is the quality of your ideas inside an essay that are of importance, not other things like proper spelling, grammar and vocabulary. You'd be wrong. Basic errors will piss off your marker and reduce your essay's readability. You have to respect that these guys have spent years grooming their own writing and they are seriously sharp and unforgiving on errors. A First class essay will have mastery over these basics. This is the first hoop.

Advanced understanding

This is the single most important thing to have if you want to write at a First class level. Not only does this tell the reader you know your stuff but it also sets you up for all those other things a First needs, which I'll speak about in a sec.

How to do it? Read. Read. And then read a bit more. A good benchmark for when you have read enough is that the references start becoming achingly familiar and no important new ones pop up. Considerable investment of time is needed; cramming simply won't work at this level.

Once this is done you will need to get it straight in your head. There are several effective ways to do this: teach someone else what you know, write a brief article about for a newspaper, make a diagram.

In all these cases, you are translating your knowledge into a simpler form that forces you to be clear by getting intimate with the logic flowing through material. It also gives you the chance to enliven and have fun with the concepts, which should forge better memories.

Once you have reached this level you will be fluent with in-house debates (e.g. modularity/connectionism, user-centred design/system-centred design, mind-brain dichotomy/mind-brain holism, serial/interactive, nativism/empiricism and so on). These arguments, their proponents and the evidence that is used in their support should be achingly familiar to you. Beyond this bifurcated, black and white - 2.1 - view, you will know the subtleties of theories and arguments - you will be at one with grey.

This refined understanding of the big picture and its smaller brushstrokes will mean you can quickly set out an argument in a pithy introduction, write with brutal clarity and relentless relevance and - most important - be unabashedly critical and glitteringly creative. I'll expand on each of these a bit.

A super-concise introduction

See my post on introduction writing for more on this. Briefly though, you should have a quick introduction to the area, a specific statement about the issue at hand, an idea of the route you are going to take and the conclusion you will arrive at. (Note how this is almost identical to an abstract.)

Brutal clarity

This means the reader is treated to an effortless journey through your argument, free from tangling structure, overgrown vocabulary and irrelevant obstacles. Every sentence will be suffused with a crispness and will elegantly pass the baton from the previous sentence to the next.

Relentless relevance

Every sentence should be working for you; use it to answer the question, or lose it. Anything not maintaining the flow of logic or evidence will be spotted by a marker's keen eye and cause upset. So many essays fall down because they give answers to adjacent questions. Keep referring back to the question with explicit sentences that actually answer it.

Unabashed criticism

Take a very low view of academic papers. Assume they are wrong and that they have something to prove to you as you are reading them and you will see the weaknesses more easily. When you do this don't tip-toe around flakiness, attack it explicitly. Don't be afraid of published scientists with lots of letters after their name. The whole point of this degree is to get you thinking for yourself. It's a great feeling taking giants down a peg and actively looking for the opportunity to do so will sharpen your nib.

Glittering creativity

There is usually a painful discord in the recent literature. That's what being at the fractious, creative edge of science is like. Armed with your advanced understanding and critical outlook you will be able to spot weaknesses in how people are uncovering and making sense of the unknown. Critiquing is good but real rewards await for those not only satisfied to criticise the food, but go ahead an open their own restaurant. That is, propose your own theory.

One way of doing this is to hook up the best bits of other theories that haven't met before. This is something I did lots. Another way of doing this is to come up with something truly new and amazing. I've never been good enough to do this.

And a conclusion to hold all the strings together and announce lift off

See my post on conclusion writing for more on this. Briefly though, gather up all the points you have made and then package them up for the reader in a neat sentence to finish the essay on, which undeniably answers the question and avoids the platitudes.

Saturday, 17 May 2008

Conclusions and Balloons


I have blogged about getting the flavour of your introduction right to impress your reader. Now it's time to think about how to finish off.

For this we are going to employ the use of some helium balloons for the mother of all contrived analogies. What we want to do is make the marker take off like this at the end of the essay:

How do we do it? What we will need are lots of well-inflated balloons all tied together. The balloons are the points in your essay. The lift they give is the force of your argument. If they don't have anything in them they ain't gonna fly. So, in your essay make sure all your points are supported by empirical reference or logic, and there are lots of them.

Now, if you hand someone a load of balloons that aren't bound together what you have is minor disappointment and a load of wasted balloons that are probably going to confuse a flock of birds. You might as well not have bothered inflating them. In other words, if your points aren't nicely drawn together at the end you aren't going to get the desired effect. The conclusion is the place to tie up all the balloons and announce the lift off.

What follows is the crudest possible way of constructing an essay. It a guideline not a rule. Don't follow it to the letter but use it to see how you can go about constructing your conclusion by drawing on the points you have made earlier.

Intro
-Intro, issue, route, destination

Para 1
-Point 1
-Summarise paragraph point 1 and relate back to Q (P1P)
Para 2
-Point 2
-Summarise paragraph point 2 and relate back to Q (P2P)
Para 3
-Point 3.
-Summarise paragraph point 3 and relate back to Q (P3P)
Para 4
-Point 4
-Summarise paragraph point 4 and related back to Q (P4P)

Conclusion
-Summarise the issue outlined at start
-P1P
-P2P
-P3P
-P4P
-Drumroll...and explicit answer to main question which will be ringing in marker's ears as they finalise your mark.

So for conclusions remember this: tie up your balloons and announce lift off!

Friday, 16 May 2008

Writing references

mark78 @ Flickr

People have clearly developed a hunger for the posts on writing style. To sate that this post has a few references that you might like to explore further. It is probably one for second years to dip into next year, although it may be worth using a dead moment to take a look at them now before exams begin.

Taines, C. (2007). A practical guide to writing for psychology. New York: McGraw Hill.

Smyth, T. R. (2004). The principles of writing in psychology. New York: Palgrave Macmillan

O'Shea, R. P., Moss, S., & McKenzie, W. (2007). Writing for psychology (5th. ed.). Melbourne: Thomson Australia.

Findlay, B. (2006). How to write psychology research reports and essays (4th ed.). Frenchs Forest, Australia: Prentice Hall.

Burton, L. (2007). An interactive approach to writing essays and research reports in psychology (2nd ed.). Milton, Australia: Wiley.

Beins, A., & Beins, B. (2008). Effective writing in psychology: Papers, posters, and presentations. New York: Blackwell.

Ambiguous pronouns

If you use pronouns - like "this”, “that”, “they”, “these”, “those” etc - make sure it is clear what they refer to, otherwise do not use them. It's just another of those things to avoid reader confusion.

Wednesday, 14 May 2008

Signposting


Signposting is helpful for getting around a place. And essays can be confusing places. So, just like their physical namesakes, when used sparingly and at the right places they can make all the difference to someone trying to find their way around your essay.

Personally, I find them helpful at the start of new paragraphs. They help provide the zip line for reader to glide down as they read. They're just another way of being an altruistic writer.

A signpost might take the form of something like this: "Having discussed how deprivation negatively affects linguistic and communication skills, why deprivation causes these effects will now be examined."

Monday, 12 May 2008

On quantity

florian_b @ Flickr


You'll often hear people asking each other how many pages they wrote in the exam as they exit, as if pages were somehow related to marks (even if that were true it would be confounded by writing size.)

I think you could probably write a pretty sweet answer on two sides (if your handwriting were on the smallish size). I know you could write a terrible answer six sides long.

The point is length doesn't matter; it's how you use it - how you write it - that counts.

I say this because there is often the temptation to try and fill the pages out of some anxiety that the marker will be unimpressed by a pithy offering.

The marker will be unimpressed by a bloated, descriptive, unfocused answer. So, write a concise, persuasive, focused answer and completely forget about how many pages you fill in an exam.

Comparisons

clspeace @ Flickr

Another thing I picked up on from the essays before MediaMax imploded: be careful with comparisons, which inevitably crop up all over the place.

Saying "Females performed worse for Condition A" is meaningless because what other group did they perform worse than? The monkey wizards?

While we're talking about "Condition A", I should mention I don't like refering to conditions by a letter because it is as clear as a brick to the reader. Give it some meaninful name.

So all together, "Females performed worse in the Banana Magic condition than the Monkey Wizards.

Wrong apostrophe's

Tesco seem to piss incorrect signs out of their arse on a daily basis. For a litany of their agrammaticism see this collection. (Perhaps that's why the majority of the public incorrectly call them "Tesco's" - the grammar gods are redressing the balance for all the missing apostrophes).

I just walked past the Carphone Warehouse which informed me "iPod's for sale". Unless they were just selling the one - a strange economic practice for a major retailer - that means someone wasn't listening in class. So, if the title of this post didn't raise an eyebrow, here's a reminder on how they work.

1. The possessive apostrophe denotes belonging, like in "Tesco's fruit" or, if the word ends in an 's' "Ross' hair" (it's ok to stick another 's' on if you like, but I don't, e.g. "Ross's".)

However, there are a few exceptions including,

It's and its

'Its' is possessive but lacks the apostrophe because 'it's' [it is] usurps it. For example, 'It's impossible its wings came off".

'Whose' and 'who's'

'Whose' is possessive but lacks the apostrophe because 'who's' [who is] usurps it. For example, 'Beardface, who's Head of Hirsute Neuroscience at Oxford University, has a PhD student whose thesis is going to be focusing solely on the neural correlates of moustache perception.'

2. The contracting apostrophe

This simply eats up letters (e.g., don't [do not]). You should never need to use this in academic writing. Therefore, if you find yourself writing "it's" and "who's" in essays, don't: either you'll have used the wrong possessive or you are making an unnecessary contraction.

Saturday, 10 May 2008

The first bite of an essay


Don't know about you, but I find the first taste of food to be the best. It's probably a combination of the hypothalamus getting its way, some neural adaptation thereafter and a bit of the primacy effect, if we are stripping down and getting really geeky. Science aside, I probably make my "Mmm, great", "Yeah, not bad" or "Ergh! Who cooked this?" after this first bite or two. It's the same with essays: the introduction will give your reader an immediate flavour for your mark and they'll spend the rest of the time they're reading making tweaks to that figure (this is what every lecturer I have ever asked has intimated).

If you start poorly your essay will have to work damn hard to improve the marker's opinion of it. Send them reeling with a confusion blow from the start and they don't really recover. On the other hand, a punchy, crisp and explicit introduction will elevate the marker's opinion of you such that occasional weaknesses are excused and any confusion you bestow upon the reader is lessened because they still have the thrust of your argument ringing in their ears from the introduction.

I think the perfect introduction has four parts and is super-concise (fewer than 150 words)
  1. A sentence to introduce the general area.
  2. A sentence or two to introduce the specific issue at hand.
  3. An idea of the route you are going to take or any definitions that need settling
  4. A punchy statement of where you are going to end up.
I'll illustrate these with an example introduction to this mock question:

"Who is the best fighter in the University of Bristol Experimental Psychology Department?"

(1) Hand-to-hand combat between psychology lecturers is common (2) Yet, the question of who is the best fighter at the University of Bristol remains largely unspecified. (3) By evaluating a large corpus of fight data and accounting for the heavy bias in Stollery's (2007) meta-analysis (towards Stollery) (4) it will be argued that although Hood (weapon: short-sleeved shirt), Scott-Samuel (weapon: the bitingly acerbic comment) and Mike from CSG (weapon: dangerous mugshot) were strong, Bowers emerges as the clear winner with his ability to 'seriously confuse from fifty feet'.

Or more seriously
:

Which theory do you think offers the best account of consciousness?

(1) Consciousness presents science with its most frustrating problem because it is both so familiar but so tough to explain; (2) nevertheless, a number of theories have been put forward. (3) By evaluating some of these theories against their ability to accurately and parsimoniously explain a large corpus of evidence, (4) a number will be rejected in deference to an adaptive representational model of consciousness, where temporal information integration is fundamental.

So, remember the reader's first taste of your essay is very important. Given that they will probably have read lots of essays before getting to yours, 'Tango slap' your reader into sitting up and paying attention to your sharp, punchy start.

Casual language

frank-wouters @ Flickr

I wrote a post about keeping your words and style simple a few days ago. I want to refine this by making sure that you don't get too relaxed. Avoid contractions (e.g. aren't), slang (e.g. there are loads of criticisms of this study), empty phrases (e.g. 'of course' or 'obviously' - it is 'obvious'?) and weak modifiers (e.g. basically etc).

Friday, 9 May 2008

Offensive words


Some words can upset scientists in a big way. Having mastery of the basics by avoiding silly mistakes is needed for a good mark. So here are few words not to use and a few words to be careful about how you use them. I'm sure most of you have them nailed but there are always a few.

'Prove'

Scientists don't 'prove' anything: they use data to support or falsify a theory.

'Believe'

Without evidence science is a fundamentally agnostic endeavor. Therefore, something in science can only be believed once there is evidence for its existence. And when that happens there are more appropriate words to use than 'believe', like 'support', 'indicate', 'demonstrate' and so on.

'Data'

This word is actually plural. 'The data is flawed' and 'The data indicates a beard module' are incorrect. It should be 'The data are flawed' and, more subtly, 'The data indicate a beard module.' One easy way to get it right if you have difficulties is to substitute 'data' in your mind with the word 'people'. 'The people is flawed' and 'The people indicates...' just sound wrong - and they are.

'Affect' and 'effect'

'Affect' is most commonly used as a verb (e.g. Having his brain removed affected the patient's judgement). 'Effect' is most commonly used as a noun (e.g. The effect of having no brain was poor decision making by the patient). However, they can switch. When 'affect' is a noun it means feeling or emotion (e.g. the patient presented with blunted affect.) When 'effect' is a verb it means to bring about (e.g. The new drugs effected the patient's recovery from coma).

'Literally'

This grinds my gears. The need to say 'literally' indicates that the utterance should not be taken metaphorically. For instance, on Scrubs JD literally becomes a deer in the headlights when he can't think of an answer to a medical question (in one of his frequent surreal asides). However, in modern parlance it is often used like the verbal equivalent of bold - for emphasis - and I have seen it creeping into writing too. 'He literally glowed with pride', 'he was literally mental', 'she literally exploded with anger'. These don't describe an extremely proud person, a rather kooky individual and someone who is very angry; they describe someone emitting light, someone who needs to be committed and a dead person.

'Bias' and 'Biased'

This can take several forms: the singular noun (e.g., 'There was bias'), the plural noun (e.g., 'There were biases'), and the verb (e.g., 'The data were biased'). If you get confused swap in the word 'colour': 'There was colour'; 'There were colours' and 'The data were coloured'.

'Phenomenon'
and 'Phenomena'

Singular and plural respectively. 'The phenomenon intrigued the farmers' and 'The phenomena had been observed over two months on the farm.' 'Phenomenons' would not really be used in scientific writing.

'Signficant', 'Insignificant' and ' Non-significant'

Which of these three words shouldn't you use in scientific writing? The middle one. Data are never insignificant in statistical terms, they are non-significant or they fail to reach significance.

'Genes want'

In Evolutionary Psychology although it is instructive to talk about genes wanting to replicate this implies some sort of intention and it will upset evo. nerds.

'Less' and 'fewer'

The rule is 'fewer' if you can count the items (i.e. plural), 'less' if you can't (i.e singular). Supermarkets perennially get this wrong at their checkouts, ad campaigns (e.g. Tesco's "Use less bags") and even corporate material (like on this J Sainsbury plc page where "use less bags" is also used).

Any emotional words

Salting and peppering your writing with emotional adjectives is not needed.

'In my opinion' or 'personally'

Probably ok for Consciousness but really you should leave phrases like this at the door.

Hedges



This is a classic Guardian ad. In the first eight seconds we conclude from the evidence the man is running away. After the next eight seconds the conclusion is that he is stealing a bag. In the last part we see that he saves the man from some falling masonry.

Now let us imagine that the middle part were the only part we had seen. Scientifically, it would be imprecise to say 'The man is stealing the bag'. This is because there may be (and indeed is) an alternative explanation.

It so happens that you know there is an alternative explanation because you have seen the ad through to its end. However, in scientific life there isn't the luxury of having all the points of view - they are still to come. You must still acknowledge that. Therefore, any conclusions made must nod towards the contingency of knowledge, they must leave room for uncertainty, they must anticipate the reader's possible rejection; in short, they must always hedge.

To infuse your writing with tentativeness and possibility, you will need to salt and pepper your language with words from the hedging arsenal, things like 'may', 'might', 'could', 'suggest', 'indicate', 'seems possible', 'implies' 'if', 'possibly' and so on.

In the Guardian Points of View ad, instead of "The man is stealing the bag" good scientific writing would say "The man may be stealing the bag", "The man could be stealing the bag", "The evidence indicates the man is stealing the bag" etc.

Hedging makes scientific writing fuzzier, but it makes it a whole lot more precise. You are saying. 'Hey there reader, based on the info I have it is likely that this is what is going on but just want to let you know that there may be other causes so please don't kick my arse if you later find out I'm wrong.'

(Hedging also acts as rather nice padding for criticisms. It may feel weird taking down guys whose job it is to think about this sort of stuff. So, instead of coming out with a categorical 'You're wrong', the introduction of a little 'may' leaves room for future discussion and fewer enemies.)

Thursday, 8 May 2008

Spilling the beans fast

mayaevening @ Flickr

Had a few emails this week about structuring paragraphs. My main bit of advice here is the title of this post: spill the beans fast. That means saying your point before giving evidence for it.

You are not writing detective fiction. The conclusion you arrive at in a paragraph doesn't have to be a wonderful 'aha!' surprise to the reader. It's better if it isn't.

So when you are writing, (1) state your point outright. (2) Then support it. (3) And then explicitly relate it back to the question if the point's done.

E.g.,
(1 SPILL THE BEANS) Tom Cruise is a nutter. (2 EVIDENCE) This, this, this, this, this, this and this. (3 SUMMARY) Taken together, the evidence indicates that Tom Cruise is bat-shit crazy.

Obviously, the way I have laid it out here is rather stark and if you were to write an essay which used this method doggedly it would be a jolty read. However, beneath the nuance and sophistication of essays and papers with better suspension, if you look deep enough into the structure, you will find this method at work.

(Watch this brilliant spoof of Tom below; the mannerisms are just perfect)



Wednesday, 7 May 2008

Sentence minimalism

“I believe more in the scissors than I do in the pencil” - Truman Capote

Bad papers, essays and writing in general use overly-long sentences. When you are dealing with difficult stuff inside the sentences don’t add to the confusion by making your sentences themselves difficult. Long sentences produce more cognitive sweat and deliver comprehension a harder kick in the nuts than shorter sentences. They are the enemy of effortless reading.

The most actionable way of achieving this Zen state of brevity is to avoid multiple subordinate clauses or run-on sentences, which means your reader is not saddling and unsaddling the whole time. Two commas are more than enough for a sentence and if there are any more it can be chopped up.

Then there are those bloated sentences. Constant revision of your work should help trim them down. If words aren’t buying you something say bye to them. Waffle is costly.

Quite a lot of bloatiness I've spotted on the uploaded essays is repetition of an experiment's method and results. Carve it off; try blending the two together.

For example,

"Functional magnetic resonance imaging was carried out on 23 participants by Beardface (2008) to establish whether there was a 'beard module' in the human visual system. Beardface found the neuroimaging revealed a distinct island of activity in the inferotemporal cortex"

can easily be written as,

"Functional magnetic resonance imaging on 23 participants found a distinct island of activity in the inferotemporal cortex with the presentation of beard stimuli (Beardface, 2008). This little change amounts to a halving of the word count.

Overall, you should be aiming for sentences like Apple design; all that is needed is there and nothing more. You should get the feeling that your words delicately pick up your idea and place it softly into the reader’s mind. Sentences that are lengthy, bloaty or repetitive will deploy clumsily - a discourtesy for which the marker may punish you.

So. Keep. Them. Short.

Personal Genteelism

Some people have asked me about using "I" in essays. Although there are some areas of scientific publication where this is (becoming) acceptable, I recommend that you avoid it for the moment, unless you have cleared it with a specific lecturer.

You should usually be able to state your position in third person. So instead of "I think the data are unreliable for the following reasons" you should say "The data are unreliable for the following reasons."

The other thing you can do is refer to yourself as "the author". I would avoid frothy phrases like "the present author of this communication" because you sound like a dick. Keep it simple.

Tuesday, 6 May 2008

Verbal overgrowth


Superlative writing is imbued with an unornamented elegance rather than appropriating a sesquipedalian demeanor. Or put better, the best writing is simple, not complex. The advice here is: Don’t be pretentious and puffed up with your vocabulary or style. It's all over the essays on the hub, this strange top-button-done-up register.

I am sure many of you have right-clicked and selected 'Synonyms' (or for the geekier, Shift+F7) thinking that you were cunningly upping your essay’s intellectual prowess.

You are not alone. 86% of Stanford undergrads admitted to doing the same. The figure is probably higher once you factor in the dishonest and those in denial.

However, as you should have felt at the start of this post, dressing up complexity as sophistication is annoying, fogging up the clarity of reading.

At best, markers are going to perceive this as immature writing; at worst, as a (deceitful) substitute for actual understanding. In any case, you are not doing yourself any favours.

So, ironically, despite your best attempts at coming across more intelligently you will achieve the precise opposite by injecting some collagen into your words.

Cognitive science supports my point. In Oppenheimer (2006) “[f]ive studies [on undergrads] demonstrate[d] that the loss of fluency due to needless complexity in a text negatively impacts raters’ assessments of the text’s authors.”

In short, readers really won’t like you pimpin' your vocab and style for no good reason. I leave you with this spot-on quotation:

"Fools ignore complexity;
pragmatists suffer it;
experts avoid it;
geniuses remove it."
(Alan Perlis)

(I should add my point is specifically about unnecessary complexity of vocabulary. This is not a diktat against complexity of vocabulary per se because sometimes longer words do communicate meaning more piquantly than their horizontally-challenged siblings. So, as some clever person once said, make it as simple as it can be, and no simpler.)

Answering the question



In March 2004 the then-White House Chief-of-Staff and counsel Alberto Gonzales rather dubiously went to the hospital room of John Ashcroft, the US Attorney General, to obtain the reauthorization of a domestic wiretapping program.

In this video, after oddly commenting on it being the reporter's birthday (her retort is spot on: "I didn't realize the intel. brief was so far reaching"), Bush is asked a straight-forward question about this issue.

As you can see, he jerks around the question uncomfortably, visiting several adjacent areas including his comfort-blanket alarmist edict that "an enemy lurks".

This is not a Bush-bashing post (the blogosphere is overflowing with them) but the President's style of answering sets me up nicely to talk about what is the number one mistake in essays that I have seen (including on the online hub), made myself and been told about by lecturers. It's the one thing that if a lot of you stopped doing you would see a dramatic rise in your marks.

It is simply what Bush does here: avoid answering the question by talking about stuff vaguely related to the question (domestic security in this example).

The empirical literature has something to say about this: Campbell et al (1998) found that one of the big reasons for poor grades in essays is due to a lack of understanding about what is required of an answer.

Many students think that a good essay is rich in research and information about the area asked - and not much else. In technical terms this is called knowledge-telling. If you do this, stop! You are a naughty person and you have most likely upset some lecturers.

The trick is not to chuck the ingredients at the marker but to serve them up with a nice tasty dish. That is, you need to do some knowledge-transformation.

One of the things the Campbell et al study found was that those getting higher marks "…engaged in processes of reconstruction rather than “knowledge telling”" and "built “arguments” rather than “information” when structuring and drafting their essays".

Imagine the question, 'What (if anything) is wrong with an empiricist view of the mind?' That should have been a question in your coursework: it was a question in my exam.

A bad answer will go off on one, answering the separate, unasked question 'Tell me everything you know about empiricism (and behaviourism and constructivism and domain-generality and nativism and modularity and domain-specificity).' It will waste time talking about theoretical and empirical fluff - made fluffy by the lack of any direct relevance to the question.

A better answer may very well use the same facts that the bad answer used but it will use those facts in service of a point. It will be using evidence to say 'Hey, this study on G-SLI is pretty bad news for empiricism' or whatever. In short, it will be using relevant information to argue. You might think this is forehead-smackingly obvious but your essays on the hub suggest that this point is not translating into your behaviour.

For people wondering how to shift gears from knowledge-telling into knowledge transformation - and let your reader know you are doing this - I would simply add in an explicit statement at the end of each paragraph. Something like, "Taken together, the evidence from these two studies strongly support the empiricist notion of the mind."

Before you start writing your paragraph in exams have an idea of how this sentence will read. This will not only make your writing more relevant but will chuck a grappling hook up the page and lodge in the essay question letting the marker see the link between what you are saying and what they have asked. This might seem a bit clumsy but I would rather be slathered with the clumsy brush than have marks carved off for being irrelevant.

If you answer questions by irrelevantly telling and not relevantly transforming, you're just like Bush. And no one wants that.

Writing

gep @ Flickr

I have had a peek at some of your essays up on the online hub and thought as the exam season pushes back from the future onto the present the next sensible thing to do is start writing about writing.

This is an area where essay feedback is weak; you are rarely told how to improve your writing. Markers just don't have the time.

That's a shame because I would guess that a very substantial chunk of your degree marks will be contingent upon the way your thoughts leave your body via your fingers onto the page.

So, I'll try and get some posts on how to make your writing more concise, precise and generally nice.

I'll start with the most general gem:


This is such an important point. First, good writing should be effortless to read. Some people are selfish writers: they don't show enough consideration for the reader.

Second, and more importantly, this effortlessness of reading requires effort of writing. The essays that score fewer marks on the hub can blame their lost marks on a lack of such effort. The research, the innovation and criticism are there - it's just the writing to gel all those things together is missing. In the coming posts hopefully you'll find more gel to use.